You are here

An invitation to discriminate

When news broke that Grindr shared the HIV status of its users, there was rightly uproar. But, as Joao Florencio argues, that the company passes on data to external parties isn’t the point.

There has been an enormous groundswell of public condemnation after reports emerged recently that hook-up app Grindr has been sharing data on the HIV status of its users to two external analytics companies it was working with. Most of the uproar has focused on data ownership and privacy — but to get to the heart of the problem, it pays to rewind the story and look at how and why Grindr introduced HIV status as one of the stats its users are invited to disclose.

Since the 1980s, HIV has played a central role in the development of gay masculinities — and even today we’re still compelled to define ourselves according to it. As many people have said before: “We are all living with HIV”, whether by living with the actual virus or by being expected to position ourselves in relation to it — that is, to state on which side of the positive/negative binary we fall on.

No surprise then that in 2016, Grindr introduced “HIV status” as one of the “stats” its users are invited to provide about themselves. Pitching the decision as a way to “support the health and safety of users worldwide” was part of Grindr’s move towards rebranding itself as a company that promotes “justice, health, safety, and more for LGBTQ individuals around the globe”. But given that HIV stigma remains prevalent worldwide, and that Grindr profiles’ stats are used as a way of filtering out “undesirable” profiles, Grindr’s intention of ending stigma by inviting people to disclose their HIV status may have a very different impact.

HIV status is just one of a list of measures against which Grindr users can define themselves. The full list reads as follows:

  • Age
  • Height
  • Weight
  • Body type – Toned, Average, Large, Muscular, Slim, Stocky
  • Position – Top, Vers top, Versatile, Vers bottom, Bottom
  • Ethnicity – Asian, Black, Latino, Middle Eastern, Mixed, Native American, White, South Asian, Other
  • Relationship status – Committed, Dating, Engaged, Exclusive, Married, Open Relationship, Partnered, Single
  • My Tribes – a long checklist of categories, including Trans, Discreet, and “Poz” (HIV positive)
  • I’m Looking For – Chat, Dates, Friends, Networking, Relationship, Right Now

Below this list are two sections: one where a user can choose whether to display their gender identity and preferred pronouns, and one where they can display their HIV status and the date they were last tested.

None of these categories has to be selected or filled in for a user to have an active profile. But Grindr doesn’t just invite users to define themselves by these characteristics — it allows them to filter the profiles they see to show only those meeting their preferences. And there are all sorts of categories Grindr doesn’t offer its users — “hairstyle”, “favourite colour”, “favourite superhero”. So why these ones?

Giving users a choice of defining features is never a neutral decision. Instead, the set of choices provided always indicates some judgement about what ought to be valued. In a nutshell, all systems of classification are ideological. By compelling its users to either state their HIV status or withhold it, Grindr enforces a norm that someone’s HIV status isn’t just something for others to care about, but a legitimate characteristic on which to base the choice of a sexual or romantic partner.

This is out of step with the reality of life with HIV today. We’ve seen incredible progress in the treatment and prophylaxis of HIV, before and after exposure. Having an undetectably low viral load, now achievable with antiretroviral drugs, means someone won’t be able to transmit the virus — and condoms and PrEP are highly successful at preventing HIV infection. Yet Grindr still offers HIV status as a marker of identity.

That the company has shared the resulting data with external parties isn’t the point. By making HIV status one of the stats available to its users, the company continues to invite them to disclose their HIV status and to discriminate on the basis of other users’ answers. Granted, disclosure of HIV status is not compulsory, but the very invitation to do so puts HIV-positive users in a bind: if they disclose it, they’ll have to face being potentially discriminated against; if they don’t give an answer, they will likely be seen to be hiding their status; if they answer “negative”, they’ll have to commit to lying.

Whichever way users answer it, Grindr’s invitation to disclose HIV status arguably still positions HIV-positive folk as solely responsible for halting HIV transmission. That is too heavy a burden for one partner to carry. In the end, sex and pleasure always involve decisions on assessing and managing risk — and those decisions are incumbent on all people involved, regardless of “status”.



latest news

June 22, 2018
Two years since its launch, MyLife+ is now recognised as the go-to app for people with HIV in Australia.
May 9, 2018
The federal government's budget details were released last night. Here's a community response.
March 29, 2018
We’re not talking about recovery parties here, but the post-recovery recovery when the festivities have ended.
March 21, 2018
The world has lost one of the most respected scientists in the field of HIV/AIDS, Professor David Cooper.
March 21, 2018
The cost of PrEP (pre-exposure prophylaxis) is to be drastically reduced from 1 April
February 12, 2018
The annual awareness day on 9 March is aimed at encouraging women to test for HIV.
January 22, 2018
Once again, 9 March commemorates the National Day of Women Living with HIV Australia. 
November 30, 2017
On a trip to Bali, David Menadue discovered that it pays to be clued up about travel insurance.
November 30, 2017
Armistead Maupin talks to Steven Petrow about 1970s San Francisco, AIDS and ageing.
November 30, 2017
This year marks the 30th anniversary of the AIDS Memorial Quilt. Read the story behind the icon.
November 29, 2017
They are the all-too forgotten minority: heterosexual men with HIV. Here are their stories.
November 29, 2017
In 2018, researchers will explore a number of approaches that might bring an end to the need for treatment.
November 29, 2017
As people with HIV get older and live longer, they become vulnerable to cardiovascular disease. 
August 22, 2017
A decision to subsidise PrEP has been deferred, much to the disappointment and frustration of HIV advocates.
July 26, 2017
Results from an Australian study show that HIV-positive men on treatment cannot transmit the virus.